How to contact Cormac Hogan:
my name is Weithenn (vExpert 2012 ~ 2014). Very pleased to be able to translate your writings with Duncan. Now, Traditional Chinese version already on the market in Taiwan.
Available via Tenlong Boot Store (http://www.tenlong.com.tw/items/9863473413?item_id=999390)
Available via GOTOP publishing house (http://books.gotop.com.tw/v_ACA020200)
Wonderful news – thanks for your efforts Weithenn
Is this article still relevant Cormac?
Great blog btw!!
Yes – we don’t have any control over the drivers that OEMs pace on the images, so we don’t know if they have been certified for VSAN or not. Use the health check plugin to verify that everything is good from a HCL perspective after VSAN has been deployed with the OEM images. However, you may need to install different drivers if there is a mismatch.
RAID controller testing for VSAN HCL
I’ve also opened an SR but haven’t had a lot of success in determining who is responsible for this process. Do you have any suggestions?
I wanted to reply for this article of yours: http://cormachogan.com/2015/05/07/vsphere-6-0-storage-features-part-8-vaai-unmap-changes/
but i believe it is too late now to post there, so posting here.
You have mentioned that UNMAP is supported from windows 2008 and above. But from the windows blog, https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/dn265487%28v=vs.85%29.aspx, and from our testing in lab, we see that windows supports understands thin provisioning only from windows 2012. Please correct me if i am wrong.
I understood that this functionality was also in Windows 2008, but it appears I was mistaken. Thanks for highlighting. I’ll adjust the post.
In your article “VSAN considerations when booting from USB/SD”, you mentioned that VSAN traces need at least 500 MB of space. However, official VMware document (https://www.vmware.com/files/pdf/products/vsan/VMware-TMD-Virtual-SAN-Hardware-Guidance.pdf) explicitly note that we are not supposed to increased the default size of 300 MB.
The reason I ask this is because I constantly have hosts that giving out “ramdisk ‘vsantraces’ is full” error. I’m thinking to increased its size, but got hesitated.
Thank you very much for your response.
Is this booting from SD or USB Aditya?
I’m not sure there is a way of modifying the layout on these devices, so please check with GSS to be sure. The issue is that these devices do not get a persistent scratch area.
When booting from a SATADOM, these “appear” like disk devices so have the 4GB scratch partition.
We are looking at improvements in this area. Let me see if I can find more info.
Cormac, apologies for jumping on this thread… but could you raise the question internally, as to how after I follow the bootstrapping VSAN VMware document, I can then migrate the standard switches created during this process to distributed switches when the vcsa / psc are sat on the vsan datastore that the bootstrapping process creates?. The document says it can be done.. we are now stuck in the middle of an NHS project to get vsan / horizon in place (using vDS) however after following the document we are stuck with std switches..
Trying to find someone who can validate it Paul. Unfortunately the author of the paper is no longer with VMware.
Hi Cormac, many thanks for taking the time to check. I understand you must be busy and this isn’t your document. So your help is much appreciated.
I’m just toying with the idea of using 1 of the 4 hosts to create a local VMFS to deploy psca and vcsa to. Then use this vcsa to deploy a vsan using the remaining 3 nodes and then attempt to storage vmotion the psc and vcsa to the 3 host vsan datastore I created.. then once that is done, blow away the disk config on the host I used to create the temp VMFS and ultimately put this host in to the 3 host VSAN cluster to give it the 4th host..
Have you storage vmotioned a vcsa over to a VSAN in this way in your lab/test?.
I haven’t done that Paul, but if all the networking is in place, it should theoretically work. Sorry I can’t be of more help. I’m on the road so I can’t try this out for you either.
Hey Cormac, the svmotion migration of the VCSA & PSC to the VSAN datasore all worked fine as all networking was in place. I’d be interested to see if a solution to the migration to distributed switches from standard can be achieved after the bootstrapping of VSAN has taken place.. because logically that would be the next step for folks like us who are in a greenfield environment.. staying at standard switch config would have made the NIOC impossible so it was quite a show stopper.
Anyhow the migration to the VSAN datastore all worked out well, thanks for your communications Cormac,
The hosts are booting from USB drive.
I found another article on the web referring to your article that explain how to increase this ‘vsantraces’ partition.
But I’ll open a ticket to GSS, just to be sure.
Thank you very much Cormac.
are you also into VSAN managed by the ruby console with newly 6.2 features? Found: vsan.sizing. on the rvc but no documentation on that anywhere…
Let me look …
This vsan.sizing. is “future-proofing”. This RVC extension has not yet been implemented, but we “may” implement something around it going forward.
Do you have any insight on why my ESXi hosts (2 out of 3-node cluster) would be running the vsanTraceReader process at 100%?
Result of ‘zcat vsantraces–2016-05-03T03h27m38s818.gz | /usr/lib/vmware/vsan/bin/vsanTraceReader.py > vsantracerlog.txt’ is here.
Afraid not – please speak to support Steve.
Hello, i love your blog and try to understand the write process of vsan. But after reading a lot of things i still have some issue about the write path. I understand that vsan is all about object and than an object have a maximal size of 250Gb. So my question is that an object is tight to a specific disk group? Or an object will be span to multiple disk group ?
Same i understand that the write will be aggregate in the ssd (write cache) of a disk group, so the question is the 1mb chunck will be destage on all disk or only on the disk of the disk group?
I try to understand at the end if my VM will be write to 1 disk group and replicate to another one, or if at the end the chunck will be put everywhere on the cluster.
A1. No, an object is not tied to a specific disk group. It can be made up of multiple components, which can span disk groups, and the components themselves can span different disk/disk groups depending on size.
A2. 1MB chunks are per disk device.
A3. VSAN may decide to split up a component across multiple disks and disk groups, depending on size and available space. However the destage process is local to a disk group, as the cache device only caches blocks for its own disk group.
i’ve had a problem using Vvol in 3par 7200c storage, let me explain: I use vmware vcenter solution to create virtual machines in a HP blade system. Suddenly one of the virtual machines lost 2 of which had 4 HD’s. Vcenter only shows that there are 2 .vmdk, but when I access 3par CLI and use the comand showvvolvm I can see that actually there are 4 .vmdk. I want to recover these 2 lost .vmdk, can you help?
I’d recommend opening an SR with both VMware GSS and HP support to recover from this situation John. Let me know how it goes.